How to Choose a Roofing Contractor: Boston Homeowner's Checklist

Here is how to choose a roofing contractor. Boston homeowners should get at least three written, itemized estimates, look up each company's Home Improvement Contractor registration on the state's MA Contractor Hub, confirm who holds the Construction Supervisor License for the job, and make the contractor pull the City permit. Then sign a contract that meets Massachusetts law and pay no more than one third up front. Most of those checks are free and take minutes. Skipping them can cost you access to state arbitration and the Guaranty Fund if the job goes bad.

Updated November 16, 2026 · Licensing & Permits

How to choose a roofing contractor: Boston checklist in order

The Office of Consumer Affairs and Business Regulation, which runs the state’s Home Improvement Contractor program, puts it plainly: picking the contractor is the most important part of a renovation. For a roof, that decision is also usually made in a hurry, with a stain spreading on the ceiling. Work through the list anyway. Most of it takes an evening.

  1. Collect at least three written, detailed estimates.
  2. Look up each company’s HIC registration and complaint history.
  3. Find out who holds the Construction Supervisor License for your job.
  4. Get proof of liability and workers’ compensation insurance.
  5. Call references from recent jobs.
  6. Agree that the contractor will pull the Boston permit.
  7. Sign a written contract that includes everything state law requires.
  8. Keep the deposit at or under one third.
  9. Get the workmanship warranty in writing.
  10. Know where to go if something goes wrong.

The sections below explain each step and what to look for.

Compare written estimates line by line

The state’s homeowner guidance recommends interviewing at least three contractors and asking each for a written, detailed estimate. Three prices on a page tell you very little. Three itemized scopes tell you a lot, because roof estimates differ mostly in what they leave out.

When the estimates come in, check that each one answers the same questions:

  • How many existing layers come off, and does the price include disposal?
  • What happens when rotten roof boards turn up? Look for a stated allowance or a per-sheet price for replacement decking, so the surprise is priced before the tear-off.
  • Where does the ice barrier membrane go? Massachusetts requires it, so an estimate that does not mention it is incomplete.
  • Is flashing at chimneys, walls, skylights and dormers new, or reused?
  • What ventilation is included at the ridge and eaves?
  • Which shingle or membrane, by brand, product line and color?

That last point matters for the contract too. The state’s sample contract asks the contractor to describe the work in detail, including the type, brand and grade of materials. If one bid says “architectural shingles” and another names the exact product, you are not comparing the same roof.

Be wary of any estimate written after a ten-minute look from the driveway. A good roofer will want to see the attic, because that is often where leaks, ventilation problems and ice dam damage show up.

Check the two numbers: HIC registration and CSL

Massachusetts uses two separate credentials, and a roofing job often needs both.

HIC registration is about consumer protection. Contractors and subcontractors who solicit, bid on or perform work on an existing, owner-occupied home with one to four units must be registered. There is no exam; the contractor pays a fee and a one-time contribution to the Guaranty Fund. Registration is what gives you access to state arbitration and the fund if things go wrong. The law does not cover new construction, buildings with more than four units, or investment, vacation and second homes.

The Construction Supervisor License is about competence. It requires passing an exam on the state building code and is generally required for work that involves a building’s structural elements. For roofs, the Specialty roof covering license covers roof covering work, including replacing up to 25 percent of the sheathing and sistering up to 25 percent of the rafters. Bigger structural repairs need an unrestricted or one and two family license. Our guides to the Massachusetts contractor license and Home Improvement Contractor registration go deeper on both.

How to check:

  • Search the company on the MA Contractor Hub for registration status and complaint history, and confirm the CSL status of whoever will supervise.
  • Ask to see the HIC identification card the state issues to every registered contractor.
  • Look for the HIC number on the company’s website and ads. The state says advertising is required by law to show it.
  • Check the Office of Public Safety and Inspections and the Better Business Bureau for complaints or disciplinary action.

If a company does not show up on the Contractor Hub, the state lists several possible reasons: an expired registration, an unresolved complaint, unpaid fees, or a suspension or revocation. Any of those is reason enough to keep looking.

Insurance and references

Ask for proof of liability insurance and, where it applies, workers’ compensation coverage. The state’s sample contract suggests getting the insurance company’s details so you can confirm the coverage yourself rather than relying on a photocopy. Roofing is work at height on your property, and if someone falls you want it to be clear whose policy responds.

For references, the state recommends asking in writing for the contractor’s three most recent projects, with homeowner names and phone numbers, and then actually calling them. Useful questions: Did the crew start when promised? Did they find rotten decking, and was the extra cost what the contract said it would be? Did the permit inspection pass the first time? How was the yard after the last day? Would you hire them again?

How do I find a reliable roofing contractor? Boston permit rules help

The permit is a quiet filter. The City of Boston handles replacement or repair of an existing roof, with no structural changes, as Short Form permit work. On an owner-occupied one or two unit home, the owner or a contractor may do it. On a three-family or larger building, including one floor of a triple-decker or a condo in a multi-unit building, the City says a contractor must do the work. The work has to begin within six months of the permit being issued, and the licensed contractor has to be on site for the inspection at the end. Our Boston building permits guide covers the process in detail.

Let the contractor pull the permit. The state’s homeowner guidance is direct about why: if you apply for the building permit yourself, you may not be eligible for compensation from the Guaranty Fund, and a contractor who refuses to apply for one may be unregistered. The permit card has to stay posted at the job until the work is complete. You can look up any Boston permit by number on the City’s Permit Finder, which takes a minute and confirms the job is on record.

If your house is in one of Boston’s historic districts, roof changes can need commission approval before the permit. Our roofing page explains how that fits into the schedule.

The contract: what Massachusetts requires

State law requires a written contract for home improvement work over $1,000, and the consumer agency recommends one for every job. The required contents are spelled out on the state’s sample contract page. Paraphrased, the contract must include:

  • The complete agreement and a description of any documents that are part of it
  • Full names and street addresses of both parties (no P.O. boxes), the contractor’s registration number on the first page, any salesperson’s name, and the date signed
  • Start and completion dates
  • A detailed description of the work and materials
  • The total price, and a payment schedule with dates and dollar amounts, including any finance charges
  • A notice that contractors must be registered, with the consumer agency’s contact details
  • A three-day cancellation notice if you signed somewhere other than the contractor’s place of business, such as your kitchen
  • All warranties, with the full terms of any express warranty attached
  • A statement of whether the contract creates any lien or security interest on your home
  • A clause naming the permits needed and saying the contractor must obtain them
  • The warning, in bold type above the signature line, not to sign if there are blank spaces
  • A sentence saying no work can start until the contract is signed and you have a copy

The sample contract adds that work may not begin until both parties have a fully signed copy and the three-day cancellation period has passed. Boston’s Consumer Affairs office also suggests getting every change in writing and a receipt for every payment.

Two money rules matter most. The deposit cannot be more than one third of the total price, or the actual cost of special-order materials if that is higher, and final payment cannot be demanded until the job is complete. And the state warns homeowners never to take financing from the contractor. Contractors may not lend you money or act with a lender when the loan is secured by a mortgage on your home.

Workmanship warranty versus the shingle warranty

There are usually two warranties on a new roof, and they cover different things. The manufacturer’s warranty covers defects in the product. The contractor’s warranty, if there is one, covers the installation. Get both in writing, and attach the contractor’s full terms to the contract as the state requires.

The difference shows up years later. The National Roofing Contractors Association notes that roof system warranties typically do not promise the roof will not leak, and that a material-only warranty usually just supplies replacement material. GAF’s current shingle warranty, for example, stops covering labor after its initial protection period. If a leak turns out to be a flashing or nailing mistake, the manufacturer is not the one who fixes it. Ask each bidder how long their workmanship warranty runs, what it excludes, and whether it transfers if you sell. Our guide on how long a roof lasts in Massachusetts explains why the number on a warranty is not a lifespan.

Red flags that should end the conversation

The state’s consumer affairs office lists the tactics it sees most often. Walk away from a roofer who:

  • Knocks on your door claiming to be in the area or to have noticed damage on your roof, which the state says is especially common after disasters. FEMA does not license or certify contractors, so a claim of FEMA approval is not a credential.
  • Says they have materials left over from another job and offers a discount
  • Pressures you to decide on the spot
  • Wants full payment up front, cash, or a check made out to a person instead of a business
  • Asks you to pull the permit
  • Will not give you an HIC number, references or proof of insurance
  • Has no HIC number on the website or advertising

If you are still working out how to choose a roofer, Boston’s Consumer Affairs office adds one more rule: do not let a contractor talk you into work you do not need. Storm damage makes everyone want to move fast. Slow down anyway.

If something goes wrong

The state offers several routes, and which ones you can use depends on whether the contractor was registered.

  • Mediation is voluntary and needs both sides to agree. In Boston, the City’s Consumer Affairs office can help, and statewide the Attorney General’s office is affiliated with local consumer groups that mediate.
  • Arbitration is available through the state program if there was a written contract, the contractor was registered when you signed, the work was on your owner-occupied one to four family primary residence, and the contractor pulled the permit. Boston’s guidance adds that the request must be filed within two years of the contract date. Registered contractors must agree to arbitrate.
  • Court is always an option. The state notes small claims court is the least costly route for claims under $7,000, and that the first step is a 30-day demand letter.
  • The Guaranty Fund can pay up to $25,000 of actual losses if you win in arbitration or court and the contractor does not pay.
  • A complaint to the consumer agency can lead to fines of up to $2,000 per violation or the loss of a registration, but it does not pay the homeowner anything.

Where we fit

Ask us for our registration and license numbers. We put the full scope and payment schedule in writing and pull the Boston permit ourselves. If you are comparing bids, send us the others too and we will tell you where the scopes differ. Our roofing service page covers houses and smaller multi-family buildings, and larger buildings are on our commercial roofing page. Contact us to set up an estimate visit.

This guide is general information for homeowners, not legal advice. Rules change and vary by city or town. Confirm details with your local building department or the state agency listed in the sources.

Common questions

How do I find a roofing contractor, Boston or anywhere else, that I can trust?

Start with neighbors and people whose roofs you have seen done, then check every name on the MA Contractor Hub for HIC registration and complaints. The state suggests interviewing at least three contractors, getting written references for each one's three most recent jobs, and checking the Office of Public Safety and Inspections and the Better Business Bureau for complaints or discipline.

What license does a roofer need in Massachusetts?

Work on an existing owner-occupied home of one to four units requires HIC registration. Work on structural elements generally requires a Construction Supervisor License; the Specialty roof covering CSL covers roof covering work plus replacing up to 25 percent of the sheathing and sistering up to 25 percent of the rafters. Larger structural repairs need a broader CSL.

How much of a deposit can a roofer ask for in Massachusetts?

Under the Home Improvement Contractor law, a deposit cannot exceed one third of the total contract price or the actual cost of special-order or custom materials that must be ordered before work starts. Final payment cannot be demanded until the work is finished to the satisfaction of everyone on the contract.

Should I pull the roofing permit myself to speed things up?

No. The state warns that homeowners who secure their own building permits are excluded from the Guaranty Fund, and that a contractor who refuses to pull the permit may be unregistered. In Boston the licensed contractor also has to be at the final inspection.

What should a roofing contract include?

At minimum, the contractor's registration number on the first page, full names and street addresses, start and completion dates, a detailed description of the work and materials, the total price, a dated payment schedule, the required notices including a three-day cancellation right, the permits the contractor will obtain, and signatures. Any express warranty must be attached in full.

A roofer knocked on my door after a storm. Should I hire them?

Be very careful. The state lists door-to-door contractors who say they are in the area or noticed damage as a common scam tactic, especially after disasters, and notes that FEMA does not license or certify contractors. Check the HIC number before you agree to anything, and never pay in cash.

What happens if my roofer was not registered?

You can still file a complaint and go to court, but you cannot use the state's arbitration program or the Guaranty Fund. Registration also only applies to owner-occupied homes of one to four units, so investment properties, vacation homes and larger buildings are outside the HIC law entirely.

Sources

Facts on this page were last checked against these sources on November 16, 2026.

  1. Mass.gov, HIC homeowner resources (accessed 2026-11-16)
  2. Mass.gov, Home improvement contract sample language (accessed 2026-11-16)
  3. Mass.gov Consumer Affairs blog, Avoiding home improvement and contractor scams (March 20, 2026) (accessed 2026-11-16)
  4. Mass.gov, HIC contractor resources (201 CMR 14.00, Guaranty Fund) (accessed 2026-11-16)
  5. Mass.gov, Learn about different Construction Supervisor Licenses (accessed 2026-11-16)
  6. City of Boston, Repair a roof (accessed 2026-11-16)
  7. City of Boston, How to get a Short Form permit (accessed 2026-11-16)
  8. City of Boston Consumer Affairs and Licensing, Home improvement and contracting tips (accessed 2026-11-16)
  9. National Roofing Contractors Association, Consumer advisory bulletin, Roof system warranties (accessed 2026-11-16)
  10. GAF, Shingle and Accessory Limited Warranty (RESWT160L-0426) (accessed 2026-11-16)

Ready to start your project?

Free, no-pressure estimates in Boston and across Massachusetts.